Professionals across various fields are increasingly adopting artificial intelligence (AI) due to its versatile advantages. Similarly, AI professionals are incorporating this technology into foreign and second-language education. AI algorithms can potentially advance language learning in various dialects, benefiting organizations, individual learners, and traditional educational institutions, diversifying opportunities, and enriching second-language acquisition. The advantages of employing AI in second-language learning are numerous.
Image credit: metamorworks/Shutterstock
In the realm of language learning, many factors converge to shape diverse outcomes. Factors such as acculturation levels, exposure to comprehensible input, attentiveness to second language nuances, and opportunities for meaningful interaction and production all play a role in shaping the language acquisition process. Learners consciously engage in the exploration of language components such as grammar and vocabulary to master essential skills—reading, writing, listening, and speaking aspects such as pronunciation.
Empowering Language Learners through AI-Powered Personalization
In recent decades, the emergence of complex dynamic systems theory and the multilingual turn have emphasized the individual distinctions among learners in the process of language acquisition. This emphasis on personalized learning has given rise to intelligent computer-assisted language learning (ICALL), a subset of computer-assisted language learning (CALL). ICALL harnesses AI principles, techniques, algorithms, and technologies, notably natural language processing (NLP), user modeling, expert systems, and intelligent tutoring systems.
The advancements driven by AI in language learning have given rise to tutoring systems, writing aids, virtual reality environments, chatbots, and adaptive learning tools. These innovations aim to offer tailored and customizable learning experiences, fostering autonomy, motivation, engagement, and efficacy. NLP-based tutoring systems, for instance, offer personalized feedback, recommendations, and materials. The latest AI developments enable real-time content adaptation to suit individual learning paces, preferences, and needs—cognitive, affective, and social.
Despite the immense potential of AI in language education, concerns loom around privacy, information security, and teacher readiness. Privacy policies and informed consent practices must be reinforced due to the necessity of data collection in AI development. Additionally, there is a need for empirical evidence verifying the pedagogical impact and learner perceptions of AI-based language learning tools. Such insights empower educators to integrate these tools effectively and judiciously into their teaching practices.
ChatGPT for Language Learning
Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformers (ChatGPT) sets itself apart from conventional AI-driven language learning tools in several ways. Its interactive nature surpasses apps with fixed responses, allowing for personalized learning paths based on users' interests, pace, and academic performance. This adaptability accelerates goal attainment, a feature lacking in apps with rigid course structures.
ChatGPT exemplifies the continuous evolution of digital technology, leveraging AI to enhance human capabilities while posing questions about its ability to mimic human writing. This concern has spurred extensive research into its pros and cons, its potential applications in language education, and its implications for language assessment and teacher training.
In the context of language learning, ChatGPT necessitates training for educators to effectively integrate it into language learning settings. Learners must also be guided in handling ChatGPT-based tasks, with a strong emphasis on ethical use. Addressing potential misuse is paramount. Research on ChatGPT's influence on motivation has revealed that it has good benefits for reading and writing skills while having no discernible effect on speaking and listening abilities. ChatGPT's ethical, pedagogical, and social ramifications have been investigated across a range of topic areas, providing both opportunities and difficulties for teachers and students.
The ChatGPT phenomenon in language education warrants a comprehensive examination, considering insights from educators and technology-experienced individuals. It underscores the evolving landscape of technology-enabled language learning, with ChatGPT at its forefront, prompting further research into its benefits and challenges in second and foreign language pedagogy.
AI-Powered Language Learning Tools and Their Impact
AI-based tools have a positive impact on language learning. It is observed that these tools enhance the learners’ learning experiences and the development of abilities, attitudes, and knowledge.
Grammar Error Correction: AI-based grammar tools effectively identified errors and provided relevant feedback. Learners using these tools demonstrated increased accuracy in English article usage and reported a heightened sense of immersion, presence, and realism during learning.
For instance, participants who utilized a digital game-based tool exhibited significant improvements in writing tasks involving English articles, outperforming other groups. These tools were perceived as effective, efficient, accurate, enjoyable, easy to use, and aligned with course materials, aiding learners in achieving their language learning goals.
Assessment and Evaluation of Conversations: In the context of speaking and listening, AI tools assessed speaking abilities, evaluated conversations, and offered relevant responses in open dialogues. Learners exhibited enhanced confidence, willingness, and reduced anxiety when speaking English. They also demonstrated improvements in listening and speaking skills, including pragmatics, cohesion, word concreteness, and the use of grammatical patterns. These tools were generally perceived as easy to use, authentic, comprehensible, and beneficial for language learning. For instance, learners who experimented with Google Assistant reported that it could boost motivation to improve English listening abilities and speaking fluency, reduce stress during English practice, and enhance listening comprehension abilities.
Vocabulary Suggestion: In a study, AI tools in the vocabulary domain automatically detected Japanese expressions, offering morphological analyses and example sentences. Learners using these tools demonstrated increased usage of emotion words and improved semantic knowledge of phrasal verbs.
Following a three-week treatment with a machine learning-based emotion synonym suggestion system, participants showed significant gains in writing tasks evaluating emotion word usage. These tools were generally viewed as interesting, easy to use, useful, and helpful for language learning. In a survey, learners expressed satisfaction with various aspects of a serious language game, including accessibility, skill acquisition, game mechanics, and challenge or reward balance.
Writing Improvement: AI-based writing tools effectively identified errors, provided feedback, assessed writing abilities, and facilitated process-based academic writing. Learners experienced reduced plagiarism, increased editing or revising time, and improved correction of rhetorical function and lexical and grammatical errors. For instance, participants using a machine translator for multiple drafts of a writing task exhibited significant improvements in writing scores and reduced lexical and grammatical errors. These tools were generally perceived as effective, easy to use, and beneficial for language learning. Learners noted that they helped identify writing strengths and weaknesses and increased writing knowledge through detailed comments.
Pronunciation Fluency Improvement: In the pronunciation domain, tools detect mispronunciations and recognize speech for diagnosis, assessment, and evaluation. These tools contributed to enhanced fluency, comprehensibility, tone, and pronunciation accuracy. Learners generally found these tools interesting, easy to use, and helpful for fluency, intonation, and tone training.
Personalized Tutoring: AI-based reading tools classify learners, assess their reading abilities, and recommend resources. Adaptive learning systems push resources tailored to individual characteristics, such as reading abilities, cognitive styles, and learning objectives. Learners who used an intelligent tutoring system demonstrated improvements in essential academic reading skills, including identifying the main idea, text structure, and inference.
Ethical Considerations and Future Developments
The following ethical considerations should be considered when using AI in language learning:
- Privacy: Safeguarding learners' personal information, including language proficiency levels and progress, is crucial.
- Fairness and Bias: AI algorithms may unintentionally perpetuate existing biases in language learning materials or teaching practices, necessitating careful consideration and correction.
- Accessibility: Ensuring that AI language learning tools are accessible to all learners, regardless of technology and internet access, is vital.
Despite these challenges and ethical considerations, AI language learning tools can be valuable supplements to traditional teaching methods. They should not replace human interaction entirely but rather enhance language learning experiences. Transparency in how these tools operate and handle learner data is essential to inform users and promote informed decision-making.
Future developments in AI language learning tools include:
- Integration with Virtual Reality and Augmented Technologies: Incorporating virtual reality and augmented reality into AI language learning tools could offer more immersive and interactive learning experiences, simulating real-life scenarios and providing real-time language assistance.
- Enhancements to NLP: Improvements to NLP algorithms may result in more advanced AI tools that can comprehend and produce complex language as well as more correctly identify and repair errors.
- Enhanced Personalized Learning Algorithms: New developments in individualized learning algorithms may allow AI technologies to provide highly customized learning experiences that instantly adjust to learners' requirements and goals.
- Integration with Other Educational Technologies: A more seamless and all-encompassing learning environment might be produced through increased integration with other educational technologies, such as learning management systems (LMS) and adaptive learning platforms.
- Specialization for Specific Industries or Purposes: AI language-learning tools may become more specialized for industries or professions, offering targeted language-learning resources tailored to specific goals, such as business or medical professions.
References and Further Readings
Roxana Rebolledo Font de la Vall, Fabián González Araya. (2023). Exploring the Benefits and Challenges of AI-Language Learning Tools, International Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Invention 10(01): 7569-7576. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18535/ijsshi/v10i01.02
Bin-Hady, W.R.A., Al-Kadi, A., Hazaea, A. and Ali, J.K.M. (2023). Exploring the dimensions of ChatGPT in English language learning: a global perspective, Library Hi Tech. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/LHT-05-2023-0200
Woo, J., and Choi, H. (2021). Systematic Review for AI-based Language Learning Tools. arXiv. DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2111.04455
Sultan A. Almelhes. (2023). A Review of Artificial Intelligence Adoption in Second-Language Learning, Theory and Practice in Language Studies, Vol. 13, No. 5, pp. 1259-1269. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17507/tpls.1305.21