The world of investment and financial advising has been transformed by the emergence of robo-advisors - algorithmic, automated platforms that provide investment management online with little human intervention. These virtual advisors are powered by artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning, reshaping the wealth and investment management landscape. AI has the potential to make financial advice and planning more accessible, affordable, and personalized for millions of retail investors worldwide. However, despite the promises, some risks and limitations must be considered as we venture into this new territory.
Image credit: ihailescara/Shutterstock
The term "robo-advisor" refers to a class of financial advisers that provides investment management advice online with moderate to minimal human intervention. The first robo-advisors appeared in 2008 in response to the global financial crisis when public trust in human financial advisers was lost. Robo-advisors represented a new model - algorithmic and automated platforms- seeking to increase transparency, reduce costs, and simplify investing for retail investors.
Over the years, robo-advisors have multiplied, fueled by exponential growth in computing power, proliferation of data, and advances in artificial intelligence. As per estimates, robo-advisors manage around $1 trillion in assets globally as of 2022, serving over 55 million users worldwide. The assets under management by Robots are projected to reach $15 trillion by 2030.
Robo-advisor platforms utilize algorithms and AI to automate and optimize most facets of investment portfolio management. This includes but is not limited to - asset allocation, portfolio modeling, trade execution, portfolio rebalancing, tax-loss harvesting, and various other services traditionally performed by human financial advisors. Additionally, they provide users 24/7 access to financial accounts via web or mobile apps, often have very low account minimums starting at $1, and charge far lower advisory fees than traditional advisers. According to Backend Benchmarking's survey, the average robo-advisor annually charges around 0.50% as an advisory fee.
The typical robo-advisor client tends to be relatively young – aged 25 to 45, tech-savvy, middle-income investors who want convenient DIY investing platforms and lower fees. However, robo-advisors are also increasingly expanding into high-net-worth investors. The critical advantage is providing disciplined, unemotional, algorithmic 24/7 advisory that minimizes biases and consistently optimizes returns over long investing horizons. This makes them suitable for first-time millennial investors and supplementing human advisors for higher-wealth clients.
Use of AI in Robo-Advisors
At the foundation of robo-advisor platforms is the extensive use of data science, machine learning, and other AI technologies. This enables robo-advisors to analyze vast quantities of market and client data to deliver hyper-personalized investment recommendations and management at scale - transcending the limitations of human advisory capabilities.
Robo-advisor platforms incorporate AI across the wealth management value chain:
Client profiling and risk assessment: Robo-advisors use online questionnaires powered by natural language processing algorithms to build a detailed profile of an investor's identity, financial situation, risk tolerance, investment horizon, and specific goals. Questions are personalized based on previous responses. This dynamic profiling steers the portfolio recommendation engine.
Predictive analytics and scoring: Once a client risk profile is constructed, robo-advisors analyze thousands of historical market data points using machine learning algorithms to predict the variability of returns over different time horizons for various asset allocations. These predictive analytics quantify probable upside/downside risk tailored to the specific client context, scoring different allocations accordingly.
Portfolio modeling and optimization: Leveraging quantitative insights from predictive analytics, robo-advisors can rigorously test, evaluate, and optimize tens of thousands of portfolio combinations to align the asset and sub-asset mix with an investor's risk profile and goals. This uses Monte Carlo simulations and other computational finance methods like bootstrap aggregation powered by cloud computing. The output is a customized investment strategy tailored to individual investor needs, dynamically fine-tuned to respond to changing market conditions faster than any human advisor can.
Trade execution and rebalancing: Robo-advisors use algorithms to automate portfolio rebalancing based on model drifts, disciplined calendar rebalancing, and opportunistic tax-loss harvesting scenarios by buying and selling assets while minimizing transaction costs and taxes. This rules-based execution removes all human emotion and behavioral biases like loss aversion, panic selling, etc., enforcing patient investing.
Personalization and customization: With continued collection and analysis of net flows, client activity, and shifting market dynamics, robo-advisor platforms update individual investor profiles and further tailor recommendations over time using predictive analytics to address changing needs and fine-tune portfolios. The automated advisory improves as more and more data is aggregated.
Chatbots and virtual assistants: AI-powered chatbots and conversational agents with natural language capabilities enable 24/7 customer service for investor queries without human intervention. These bots start with rule-based scripts but gain increasing contextual knowledge using deep neural networks over thousands of conversations to improve responsiveness.
Future Outlook
AI is poised to disrupt almost every aspect and role within the investment management value chain - from client-facing advisers and product managers to back-office operations and compliance teams. Advances in machine learning and open access to alternative datasets expand possibilities on both retail and institutional sides.
Some potentially transformative applications include:
- Fintech mobile apps such as 24/7 'Virtual financial assistants' provide highly customized coaching and advisory based on analysis of daily financial behaviors and expenditures augmented by environmental sensors.
- Algorithmic trading platforms powered by RNNs detect complex market temporal patterns to exploit minute-to-minute arbitrage opportunities between asset classes and cryptocurrency exchanges.
- Empathetic AI companions provide lifelong, trusted advisory services that deeply understand personal circumstances and adapt financial plans from college savings to retirement planning over the long investing journey.
- Product innovation engines that rapidly prototype and test the feasibility of new ETFs or customized structured products using simulations and scenario analysis to align with changing consumer sentiments, emerging interests, and latent preferences uncovered through NLP.
- Hyper-personalized robots that tap into the power of alternative data from satellites to smartphones to model the world's interlinked financial ecosystems and improve predictive accuracy for billions of individuals simultaneously.
Risks and Challenges
Despite the promise, there are also several limitations and risks posed by over-reliance on nascent AI technologies for mission-critical financial advisory.
Key risks include:
- Model opacity and explainability: The millions of adaptive parameters in machine learning models powering robo-advisory make model behaviors challenging to explain and audit thoroughly. More transparency into why specific investment actions are taken can erode consumer trust and adoption. Complete traceability is essential.
- Algorithmic bias and fairness: Historical biases like gender, racial, or age discrimination can creep into AI models through the data used to train them if adequate safeguards are not placed. Ensuring equitable access to quality advisory for all demographic groups is vital.
- Cybersecurity vulnerabilities: There are also heightened cybersecurity risks from mass surveillance or hacking as robo-advisors gather enormous amounts of customer data, including portfolio holdings and personally identifiable information. Predictive analytics can infer confidential information, prompting privacy concerns.
- The systemic risk from interconnected models: As robo-advisors grow very large in scale, their models react to the same market conditions in amplified ways. In times of volatility, this could trigger cascading effects and liquidity issues, endangering financial stability.
- Lack of behavioral coaching for irrational investors: There needs to be more than raw computing power to discipline the average irrational retail investor. Without human advisory elements - empathy, trust, nuanced explanations - could impede long-term investing success and compound panicked decisions.
Thus, while AI promises speed, scalability, and personalization, it also warrants caution. Blending digital capabilities with human oversight may present the ideal path forward as technologies mature. Rather than replace financial advisors, AI can augment their expertise.
The Road Ahead
To summarize, AI-powered robo-advisors have demonstrated tremendous potential to transform investment management - expanding access, reducing costs, and enhancing personalization for millions of investors in a scalable manner. Machine learning and predictive analytics usher exciting efficiencies into wealth management by automating routine manual tasks. However, it also introduces emerging risks around data security, algorithmic bias, model opacity, and inherent empathy constraints of automation. Finding the right balance will pave the path toward mass adoption.
With rapid advances in AI, there lies abundant scope for beneficial innovation at the intersection of artificial and human intelligence in financial advisory. However, responsible development addressing transparency, oversight, and accountability will be crucial as we tread this transformative landscape. The companies that build trust and value for consumers through prudent AI adoption stand to gain the most.
References and Further Reading:
Shanmuganathan, M. (2020). Behavioural finance in an era of artificial intelligence: Longitudinal case study of robo-advisors in investment decisions. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Finance, 27, 100297. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbef.2020.100297
Back, C., Morana, S., & Spann, M. (2021). Do Robo-Advisors Make Us Better Investors? SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3777387
Phoon, K., & Koh, F. (2017). Robo-Advisors and Wealth Management. The Journal of Alternative Investments, 20(3), 79–94. https://doi.org/10.3905/jai.2018.20.3.079
Tao, R., Su, C.-W., Xiao, Y., Dai, K., & Khalid, F. (2021). Robo advisors, algorithmic trading and investment management: Wonders of fourth industrial revolution in financial markets. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 163, 120421. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2020.120421